Connect with us


‘It’s getting lonely on Trump Island’: Mueller just snagged his biggest victory yet in the Russia probe

Matt Linden



Paul Manafort was the chairman of President Donald Trump’s campaign when he offered a Russian oligarch “private briefings” on Trump’s bid.

He was spearheading the campaign when WikiLeaks began dumping thousands of emails from the Democratic National Committee that had been stolen by Russian operatives.

Perhaps most importantly, he was one of three top Trump campaign officials to attend a meeting with two Russian lobbyists offering kompromat on Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton at the height of the campaign.

On Friday, Manafort pleaded guilty to two counts of conspiracy and obstruction, and Andrew Weismann, a prosecutor working for the special counsel Robert Mueller, told a federal judge that Manafort had flipped and would be cooperating “in any and all matter as to which the government deems the cooperation relevant,” including “testifying fully, completely” before a grand jury.

Patrick Cotter, a former federal prosecutor who worked with Weismann in the past, didn’t mince words when he reacted to the development.

“Manafort’s cooperation is the single most important advancement for the Mueller probe,” he said. “He is the single most important witness thus far, because his position was such that he can shed light on the most critical question of what the president knew, and when he knew it.”

‘This is a huge get for Mueller’s team’

After Manafort’s plea deal was announced, both Giuliani and the White House released statements downplaying its significance.

“Once again an investigation has concluded with a plea having nothing to do with President Trump or the Trump campaign,” Giuliani said in a statement to Business Insider. “The reason: the President did nothing wrong.”

White House press secretary Sarah Sanders struck a similar chord.

“This had absolutely nothing to do with the President or his victorious 2016 Presidential campaign,” she said in a statement. “It is totally unrelated.”

While the charges to which Manafort pleaded are unrelated to Trump, legal experts say Manafort will tell Mueller a lot more than just information about what was in the indictments against him.

“Sanders’ statement is just false,” Cramer said. “Some things are gray. This is really black and white. The Russia meeting was obviously during the campaign, the DNC hack was obviously during the campaign, as were many other events Manafort may know about.”

“The court of public opinion is one thing; the legal system doesn’t care about the spin the White House is putting on this,” he added.

Honig agreed.

Manafort’s cooperation, he said, is a massive victory for the special counsel, because “the way it works with federal cooperation is it’s all or nothing.”

“The cooperator doesn’t just talk about select people or categories,” he said. “They have to talk about everything they’ve ever done, all the criminal activity they knew about, every crime they’ve committed.”

Before striking a plea deal with a defendant, prosecutors sit down with them or their attorney for what’s known as a proffer session, which involves the defendant answering any questions from investigators, including those about their own case and other possible criminal activity they may have witnessed.

Even if Mueller’s team didn’t have the chance to sit down for a full proffer session with Manafort, experts said he almost certainly knew the broad strokes of what the former Trump campaign chairman had to offer.

Ultimately, prosecutors only agree to a cooperation deal with a defendant if the defendant gives them information that can be confirmed by other witnesses and documents.

Cotter, who was part of the team that convicted the Gambino crime family boss John Gotti after flipping his right-hand man, Salvatore “Sammy the bull” Gravano, said that was the most significant takeaway for him.

“This means Mueller’s team feels that what Manafort has to offer is not just credible, but important,” he said. “That suggests that what Manafort knows is really critical evidence about that Trump Tower meeting, who knew about it and when, and what other contacts were there between the campaign and people around Trump.”

The bottom line? Every day, Cotter said, there are one or two fewer people the president can rely on.

“It’s getting very lonely on Trump Island.”

Join The Conversation